Ancient Weapons and Hokey Religions
"The slide rule, talisman until recently of the honorable profession of engineer, is in the electronic age as obsolete as any Bronze Age relic. An archaeologist of the future, finding a slide rule and wondering about it, might note that it is handy for drawing straight lines or for buttering bread. But to assume that either of these was its original purpose violates the economy assumption. A mere straight-edge or butter knife would not have needed a sliding member in the middle of the rule. Moreover, if you examine the spacing of the graticules you find precise logarithmic scales, too meticulously disposed to be accidental. It would dawn on the archaeologist that, in an age before electronic calculators, this pattern would constitute an ingenious trick for rapid multiplication and division. The mystery of the slide rule would be solved by reverse engineering, employing the assumption of intelligent and economical design." [p. 103]
(Richard Dawkins, River Out of Eden: A Darwinian View of Life)
It would dawn on the archaeologist that, in an age before electronic calculators, this pattern would constitute an ingenious trick for rapid multiplication and division.
That is putting a great deal of intellectual burden on your average archaeologist. Take a fellow who has only seen a slide-rule in pictures - would it be obvious that the spacing of the graticules in fact allow multiplication/division? One suspects it would get labeled with a big ol' question mark.
Later an engineer might look at it and have a eureka moment and be soundly dismissed because he's not in the archeology club.
Posted by: Brian at May 16, 2007 01:46 PM